Witness counts (Pinakes)
Kill-instrument — a dataset that can test conjecturesPinakes/BHG/BHL-style per-work manuscript witness-count catalogues.
Synopsis
LLM-authored synopsis Not an articlePinakes and comparable catalogues (the Bibliotheca Hagiographica Graeca and Latina) do one specific, powerful thing: for every known Greek or Latin work, they count exactly how many surviving manuscript copies -- witnesses -- exist, work by work, rather than describing texts individually.
Because a witness count is a single hard number attached to every text in a tradition, it is the natural instrument for testing statistical laws of survival and popularity directly. Manuscript Yule process and The universality class of survival both treat the distribution of witness counts across a whole tradition as following a specific mathematical growth or survival law, and The singleton census applies a method from ecology -- estimating an unseen population from how many things appear only once -- to the many works attested by a single surviving copy. The curriculum cliff and Forgeries are fitter both ask whether a work's popularity, measured this way, predicts whether it keeps being copied at all, or whether outside factors like forgery and controversy skew the count.
Interpretive synthesis over gathered records only. It creates no article, evidence, inferon, source, or estimate.
Emergent lineage
Related pages, connected by this project's own research.
Related Pages
Other pages that share linked material with this one.
Record claim
About the production, transmission, survival, or filtering of the written/material record up to the pre-modern past itself -- scribal behaviour and e…
Greek textual transmission
Greek lost works, fragment corpora, doxographic chains, technical texts, and ancient author dossiers.
Manuscript and scribal production
Anonymous hands, production teams, witness families, codices, scribal layers, and manuscript-workshop lacunae.
Early Christian and Syriac transmission
Christian, Syriac, patristic, episcopal, and conciliar source routes before print dominance.
Byzantine lead seals
PBW / Dumbarton Oaks Byzantine lead-seal corpora.
Technical, recipe, and scientific texts
Recipe strata, agronomic source chains, astronomical catalogues, herbals, and practical technical corpora.
Union catalogues
manuscript union catalogues and microfilm/digitization censuses (vHMML, EMML, NGMPP/Nepal, NCC, Kanjur databases, national catalogues).
Charters & chanceries
DEEDS, eSawyer, cartularies, papal/royal registers, chancery output series, forgery censuses.
Open conjectures — noetic, untested
Falsifiable questions posed below the evidence boundary by the 1001 Conjectures project. They are leads, not evidence, and carry no weight in this page's assessment.
- Manuscript Yule process Supported
- The singleton census Anticipated in print · untested
- The universality class of survival Falsified
- The curriculum cliff Anticipated in print · untested
- Canon eats its siblings Anticipated in print · untested
- Forgeries are fitter Anticipated in print · untested
From the One Thousand and One Conjectures. They carry no evidential weight here; verdicts and credits live on each conjecture's own page.